| 2024-25: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Jan 29, 2025) |
| 2023-24: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Nov 30, 2023) |
| 2022-23: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Dec 6, 2022) |
| 2021-22: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Dec 21, 2021) |
| 2019-2020: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Feb 5, 2020) |
| 2013-14: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Nov 27, 2013) |
| 2012-13: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Dec 20, 2012) |
| 2011-12: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Dec 16, 2011) |
| 2010-11: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Dec 9, 2010) |
| 2009-2010: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Dec 17, 2009) |
| 2006-07: Amherst [NY] vs. St. Joseph's [NY] (Jan 3, 2007) |
| 2003-04: Holley Team Tournament (Nov 29, 2003) |
